The following is a response I wrote to someone who saw my playing on YouTube and wanted to know about the flute I’m playing. I thought I’d share it:
Hey Mark,
thanks for your kind words. I’ve only upgraded from plastic last November. My current flute is a blackwood Rudall made in 2001 by Michael Grinter. I only mention the year because Michael has updated his design since. Grinter is certainly one of the premier makers of fine Irish flutes, and some of the best (such as Kevin Crawford and Michael McGoldrick) play his tooters. However, I’m finding out that it is certainly not an “easy” flute to play and I have a long way to go growing into it. There’s a lot more “tone” locked up in there that I haven’t gotten to.
Some peeps make a big deal out of the Pratten vs. Rudall question. My plastic flute supposedly was a Pratten, and I couldn’t for the life of me find an appreciable difference (hole size/spacing, volume, amount of air). That may well have to do with my relative inexperience, but it means that until I get a lot better, it doesn’t really matter yet. The nice thing is that good flutes preserve their value well, or even appreciate over time. That means that if you can afford a good quality instrument (in the range of $800-1400), if you take good care of it and if you can wait for an honest buyer, you can always move to a different one at a minimal loss.
Good flutes usually don’t show up on eBay.
I would suggest you hang around the flute section on http://chiffboard.mati.ca. Lots of good players and a few makers (Terry McGee, Tony Dixon, Doug Tipple, Casey Burns) hang around on these discussion boards. People also advertise instruments for sale. That’s how I got mine. Patrick “Doc” Jones is also a regular. He runs http://irishflutestore.com and is a super-duper nice and honest guy to deal with. He sent me a $1400 flute to try out, sight unseen, and insisted in covering his end of the shipping costs even though I didn’t buy the flute. His commitment and service to the flute playing community is amazing. He will talk straight to you and not try to take advantage of you. He might even be interested in your Dixon as a trade-in.
Remember that if you think that your playing sucks, it’s tempting to think that the flute is at fault. However, that’s almost never the case (I’m not talking about those Pakistani and Indian flutes on eBay which are truly atrocious). Every flute has its quirks, and it’s your job to learn to live with them. There are many weak players with amazing flutes while a good player can make even a mediocre instrument sing. So much for the philosophy. I wish you good luck, satisfaction and perseverance with your passion.
– whistlinginthedark